
La Concha Key West
Best for being in the center of Old Town nightlife, restaurants, and museums — steps from Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
La Concha Key West is a 4-star Autograph Collection hotel on Duval Street for travelers who want to be in the middle of Old Town’s shops, bars, and sights. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is a historic beachfront 4-star resort better suited to travelers who want resort pools, a private beach, and water-sport access.
Updated · about 0.9 km apart

Best for being in the center of Old Town nightlife, restaurants, and museums — steps from Duval Street.

Best for a beach-resort stay with private beach access, multiple pools, and on-site water activities.
When La Concha Key West wins: choose La Concha if you want to stay on Duval Street with immediate walkable access to Old Town attractions, nightlife, and a hotel that focuses on Cuban-inspired dining and rooftop views.
When Casa Marina Key West wins: choose Casa Marina if you prefer a more traditional beach-resort experience — private beach, more pool options, larger meeting space, and a full-service spa offering on-site treatments.
Bottom line: Pick La Concha for location and Old Town energy; pick Casa Marina for beachfront, pool variety, and resort-style amenities.
| Category | La Concha Key West | Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Spanish Colonial–style city hotel on Duval Street with lively bars and rooftop villas | Historic beachfront resort with a resort layout, lawns, and water-sport activity options |
| Location | 430 Duval Street — in the heart of Old Town on Duval Street | 1500 Reynolds Street — on Old Town’s south coast with a private beach (Higgs/Florida Keys Beaches nearby) |
| Size (rooms) | 160 guest rooms (including 14 suites) | 311 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | |
| Pools | Heated outdoor rooftop pool with Conch Club Pool Bar; described as small | Two outdoor pools plus a private beach and poolside amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Perla (Cuban), El Dom (Cuban cafe), Tropicado Mojito Bar, Conch Club Pool Bar, Epicurean Market | One main restaurant and a bar/lounge plus a beach bar and pool dining (Morrison’s Market and coffee shop/cafe cited) |
| Spa & wellness | Former rooftop Top Spa is closed/converted to rooftop villas; 24-hour fitness center available | Full-service spa offering massages, facials, body treatments and spa services on site |
| Known for | Duval Street access, rooftop villas and lively evening scene | Historic beachfront location, resort pools, and larger meeting/wedding facilities |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple small meeting rooms and rooftop venues totaling roughly 1,300–2,000+ sq ft depending on source | Conference space about 976 m² (10,504 sq ft) with 7 meeting rooms |
| Parking | On-site self and valet parking for a surcharge (not free) | |
La Concha sits at 430 Duval Street in Old Town, putting shops, bars, museums, and Duval Street nightlife right outside the door.
Choose La Concha when you want to be in the middle of Old Town activity and don’t need direct beach access.
Casa Marina is on the south coast of Old Town with its own private beach and resort grounds.
Choose Casa Marina when a beachfront location and resort grounds matter more than being on Duval Street.
La Concha offers 160 rooms including rooftop 'Grand Dame Villas' — many rooms are compact city layouts suited to Old Town stays.
La Concha’s rooms favor an Old Town, urban-hotel footprint with special rooftop villa options for views.
Casa Marina’s rooms run across many categories including ocean-, pool- and beach-view rooms and multiple suite types.
Casa Marina gives more room choices for ocean or pool views and direct beach access.
La Concha focuses on Cuban-inspired food and several on-site bars clustered around Duval and the rooftop.
If you want Cuban coffee, tapas and lively Duval bars within steps of your room, La Concha is the simpler choice.
Casa Marina operates full-service resort dining with a marketplace, bar options and beach/pool service.
Casa Marina provides classic resort dining and beachside drink options for a stay centered on lounging and waterfront meals.
La Concha’s signature pool is a heated outdoor rooftop pool with a pool bar and lounge seating.
La Concha’s pool is scenic and convenient for Duval Street guests but smaller and more urban than a beachfront resort pool complex.
Casa Marina lists two outdoor pools and a private beach for guests who want water and sand without leaving the property.
Casa Marina is the stronger choice if pools plus a private beach are central to your stay.
La Concha has a 24-hour fitness center and an active Duval Street nightlife just outside the hotel.
La Concha pairs an in-house gym and direct access to Old Town nightlife, but its historic rooftop spa is no longer operating.
Casa Marina provides a full-service spa and schedule of on-site activities focused on relaxation and water sports.
Casa Marina offers more traditional resort wellness options and on-site water-based activities.

La Concha — you’re on Duval Street with bars, galleries and attractions at your doorstep.

Casa Marina — private beach plus two outdoor pools and more poolside space.

Casa Marina — full-service spa and on-site kayaking, sailing, snorkeling options.

La Concha — seventh-floor Grand Dame Villas and a rooftop terrace for sunset cocktails.
La Concha is located on Duval Street; Casa Marina is a short walk or local-transport ride away on the south coast.
Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection has private beach access; La Concha does not.
La Concha’s rooftop Top Spa is listed as permanently closed and the rooftop space was converted into villas.
Both properties welcome guests of all ages; both require a minimum check-in age of 21 for the registered guest.
Explore how La Concha Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·