
La Concha Key West
Best for being inside Old Town — steps from Duval Street nightlife, museums and walking routes.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
La Concha Key West is a 4-star, historic hotel on Duval Street in Old Town with rooftop villas and a heated rooftop pool — read this if you want to be in the middle of Key West’s bars, sights, and walkable Old Town. The Gates Hotel Key West is a contemporary 4-star property in New Town aimed at travelers who want modern rooms, straightforward amenities and easier access to the airport and marinas.
Updated · about 3.5 mi (5.5 km) apart

Best for being inside Old Town — steps from Duval Street nightlife, museums and walking routes.

Best for a modern, value-oriented stay near Key West International Airport and New Town attractions.
When La Concha Key West wins: Choose La Concha if you want to be on Duval Street with immediate access to Old Town restaurants, bars and sights, plus rooftop villas and a heated rooftop pool.
When The Gates Hotel Key West wins: Choose The Gates if you prefer a newer-style, less-touristy New Town base with straightforward amenities, on-site parking options, and quick access to the airport and nearby marinas.
Bottom line: Pick La Concha for location and Old Town atmosphere; pick The Gates for a contemporary hotel experience outside Old Town and easier airport access.
| Category | La Concha Key West | The Gates Hotel Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Spanish Colonial Revival building, historic-meets-refreshed Old Town hotel | Modern lifestyle hotel positioned at Key West’s New Town edge |
| Location | 430 Duval Street, in the heart of Old Town (walk everywhere on Duval) | 3824 N Roosevelt Blvd, New Town (closer to airport and marinas) |
| Size | About 160 rooms including 14 suites and 7 rooftop villas | 100 rooms (air-conditioned) |
| Ages / access | All-ages property; minimum check-in age 21 | |
| Pools | Heated rooftop/outdoor pool with poolside bar (small pool reported) | Outdoor pool with poolside bar; pool hours and cabana options listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: Perla (Cuban), El Dom (Cuban coffee), Tropicado Mojito Bar, Conch Club Pool Bar, Epicurean Market | Two restaurants plus a coffee shop/cafe and a poolside bar (The Blind Pig Food Truck listed among dining) |
| Wellness & fitness | 24-hour fitness center; former rooftop spa closed and space converted into rooftop villas | Fitness facilities on-site; spa/health services nearby (not an on-site full spa listed) |
| Known for | Duval Street location, rooftop villas/terrace and Old Town access | Contemporary, renovated hotel near airport and Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden |
| Parking | On-site self-parking and valet available for a surcharge (not complimentary) | Uncovered self parking available (surcharge); long-term parking options |
| Airport access | About 2–3 miles from Key West International Airport (duval/Old Town) | Approximately 2.9 km / 1.8 mi to Key West Intl. Airport (listed as nearest airport) |
La Concha stands on Duval Street in the Key West Historic District, putting Old Town restaurants, nightlife and museums a short walk away.
Choose La Concha for immediate Old Town access and an on-foot Key West experience.
The Gates sits in New Town near N Roosevelt Blvd — a more car- and parking-friendly location a short ride from Old Town.
Choose The Gates for easier airport access and to avoid Old Town crowds while still being a short ride from attractions.
La Concha offers about 160 rooms including multiple suite types and seven rooftop Grand Dame Villas created from a renovated rooftop.
La Concha favors variety and character, with distinctive rooftop villas for a special Old Town stay.
The Gates lists 100 air-conditioned rooms focused on contemporary design and straightforward comfort.
The Gates is a simpler, modern option with reliable in-room basics and accessible choices.
La Concha centers on Cuban-inspired dining and multiple bars right on Duval Street.
La Concha suits guests who want several on-site dining choices and easy access to Duval Street restaurants.
The Gates offers two restaurants, a coffee shop/cafe and casual poolside options.
The Gates provides convenient, modern dining on-site without the Old Town concentration of options.
La Concha has a heated outdoor rooftop pool with a poolside bar and sun loungers.
La Concha’s rooftop pool is handy for quick swims and sunset drinks, but space is limited.
The Gates has an outdoor pool with pool cabanas (surcharge) and a poolside bar.
The Gates provides a standard outdoor-pool setup with some paid extras like cabanas and parking options.
La Concha combines a 24-hour fitness center with immediate access to Old Town nightlife.
La Concha pairs a full fitness facility with Old Town’s evening energy — choose it if you want nightlife nearby.
The Gates includes fitness facilities and evening entertainment in a more sedate New Town setting.
The Gates suits travelers who want fitness options and low-key evenings without Old Town noise.

La Concha — on Duval Street, steps from restaurants, museums and nightlife.

The Gates — positioned in New Town with quicker access to Key West Intl. Airport and marinas.

La Concha — rooftop Grand Dame Villas and historic Spanish Colonial Revival architecture.

The Gates — contemporary room inventory and clear accessible-room options.
La Concha — it sits on Duval Street in Old Town, within easy walking distance of bars, restaurants and attractions.
The Gates is in New Town and lists the airport as the nearest major airport; it’s typically quicker to reach by car or rideshare than an Old Town hotel.
Yes. Both properties list accessible rooms and public-area accessibility features; check each hotel's specific accessible-room types for exact details.
La Concha’s former rooftop Top Spa is listed as permanently closed and the rooftop space was converted to villas; The Gates lists fitness facilities and nearby spa/health services rather than a full on-site spa.
Explore how La Concha Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·