
La Concha Key West
Best for being in the heart of Old Town, nightlife and sightseeing on foot.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
La Concha Key West is a 4-star Autograph Collection hotel on Duval Street for travelers who want direct access to Old Town's restaurants, bars, and sights. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a 4-star casual, branded beachfront resort on South Roosevelt Boulevard for guests looking for a relaxed beach‑front stay and consistent Margaritaville service.
Updated · about 3.2 km apart

Best for being in the heart of Old Town, nightlife and sightseeing on foot.

Best for a relaxed beachfront stay with a recognizable lifestyle brand and easy access to Smathers Beach.
La Concha Key West wins when you want to be on Duval Street with immediate access to Old Town museums, galleries, nightlife and the hotel's rooftop villas and rooftop terrace.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West wins when a beachside location, poolside lounging and a familiar brand experience (plus complimentary airport shuttle on request) matter more than being inside the Historic District.
Bottom line: choose La Concha for Old Town walkability, nightlife and rooftop rooms; choose Margaritaville for a more classic beach-resort feel and easier beach access.
| Category | La Concha Key West | Margaritaville Beach House Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Duval Street hotel with Cuban-inspired dining and rooftop villas | Casual tropical beach‑house resort tied to the Margaritaville lifestyle brand |
| Location | 430 Duval Street — in the heart of Old Town, steps from Duval Street sights | 2001 South Roosevelt Blvd — on the ocean side near Smathers Beach |
| Size (rooms) | 160 guest rooms (including 14 suites) | 186 guest rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | |
| Pools | Heated outdoor rooftop pool with Conch Club Pool Bar (small rooftop pool) | Outdoor pool, hot tub and poolside bar; pool cabanas (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Perla (Cuban), El Dom (Cuban cafe), Tropicado Mojito Bar, Conch Club Pool Bar | On-site restaurant, poolside bar and one bar/lounge; room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Previously had Top Spa — now permanently closed and space converted to rooftop villas | Health or beauty spa nearby (not published as a full on-site spa) |
| Known for | Duval Street address, rooftop villas and easy access to Old Town attractions | Beachfront location near Smathers Beach and a recognizable Margaritaville experience |
| Airport transfer | No airport shuttle; typical EYW transfer via taxi/rideshare | Complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle available on request |
| Accessibility & family features | Wheelchair-accessible facilities and accessible rooms available; free Wi‑Fi | Accessible features listed (elevators, accessible rooms, pool hoist); free bottled water and free local calls |
La Concha sits at 430 Duval Street in the Old Town Historic District, ideal for walking to museums, bars and galleries.
Choose La Concha if you want to be in the middle of Old Town activity and walk to attractions.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West is on South Roosevelt Boulevard with direct ocean access and easy reach of Smathers Beach.
Choose Margaritaville for a beachfront location and simple beach access outside the Old Town core.
La Concha offers 160 guest rooms including 14 suites and seven rooftop 'Grand Dame Villas' converted from the former spa.
La Concha is best if you want historic-character rooms and rooftop villa options tied to the Duval Street scene.
Margaritaville lists 186 rooms with a range of suite and resort-view options, including ocean-view and pool-view suites.
Margaritaville caters to travelers wanting easy beach or pool views and larger suite options.
La Concha focuses on Cuban-inspired dining across several on-site venues.
La Concha is the choice for Cuban-flavored meals, café options and a lively Duval bar scene.
Margaritaville provides on-site dining, a poolside bar and limited room service hours.
Margaritaville suits travelers wanting casual beachside dining and poolside service under the Margaritaville brand.
La Concha offers a heated outdoor rooftop pool with a poolside bar; the rooftop pool is relatively small per reviews.
La Concha is good when you want a social rooftop pool and quick access to downtown rather than a private beach.
Margaritaville sits by the ocean with an outdoor pool, hot tub and poolside bar; the property is marketed as a beach‑house resort.
Margaritaville is the clearer pick for guests prioritizing beach access and poolside resort time.
La Concha has a 24‑hour fitness center and an active Duval Street nightlife link; its prior rooftop spa space was converted to villas.
La Concha pairs fitness facilities with immediate Duval nightlife; don't expect an on-site spa.
Margaritaville lists fitness offerings and nearby spa/beauty services rather than a detailed on-site spa program in the supplier listing.
Margaritaville provides basic wellness facilities and beachside evening leisure; a stand‑alone on‑site spa is not published in the listing.

La Concha — steps from Duval Street bars, restaurants and historic attractions.

Margaritaville Beach House Key West — on the ocean side near Smathers Beach with poolside lounging.

Margaritaville — Margaritaville name recognition and a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle on request.

La Concha — rooftop 'Grand Dame Villas' and a rooftop terrace for sunset cocktails.
La Concha — it's on Duval Street in the Historic District with many attractions within easy walking distance.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West — it's located on South Roosevelt Boulevard with ocean access near Smathers Beach.
Margaritaville lists a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle on request; La Concha does not provide an airport shuttle per published information.
La Concha's former Top Spa is permanently closed and the rooftop space was converted to villas; Margaritaville's listing mentions a health/beauty spa nearby but does not publish a full on-site spa program.
Explore how La Concha Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·