
La Concha Key West
Best for walkable Old Town access, Duval Street nightlife, and rooftop suites.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
La Concha Key West is a 4-star Autograph Collection hotel on Duval Street in Key West’s Historic District, good for travelers who want walkable access to Old Town sights, restaurants, and nightlife. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is a large branded waterfront resort on Stock Island with a marina and multiple pools — read this if you want boating access, more resort-style amenities, or family-friendly pool options.
Updated

Best for walkable Old Town access, Duval Street nightlife, and rooftop suites.

Best for marina access, water-based activities, and lots of pool options.
When La Concha Key West wins: choose La Concha if you want to be in the middle of Old Town on Duval Street, within easy walking reach of museums, bars, restaurants, and the Southernmost Point marker — and if you prefer a smaller, historic property with rooftop villas.
When Hilton Key West Resort & Marina wins: pick the Hilton if your trip focuses on boating, renting watercraft, or you want multiple outdoor pools and resort-style recreational options (marina, bike rentals, boat tours) that are less about downtown walking access.
Bottom line: La Concha is the convenient Old Town choice for sightseeing and evening activity on foot; the Hilton is the choice for guests prioritizing a marina and on-site water recreation and larger resort facilities.
| Category | La Concha Key West | Hilton Key West Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Duval Street hotel with rooftop villas and an intimate rooftop pool experience | Large branded waterfront resort focused on marina and resort activities |
| Location | 430 Duval Street, in the heart of Key West Historic District — steps from Old Town sights | 5950 Peninsular Avenue, Stock Island — waterfront location with marina on site |
| Size (rooms) | 160 guestrooms including 14 suites | 175 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / family policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages allowed; children 17 and younger stay free when using existing bedding; minimum check-in age 21 |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool with rooftop pool bar; described as small with loungers | Six outdoor pools and a poolside bar (multiple pool areas) |
| Restaurants & bars | Perla (Cuban), El Dom (coffee/pastries), Tropicado Mojito Bar, Conch Club Pool Bar, Epicurean Market (24/7) | One restaurant plus a coffee shop/cafe and at least one bar/pool bar (supplier lists number of outlets but not restaurant names) |
| Spa | Former rooftop spa converted into Grand Dame Villas; Top Spa listed as permanently closed | Not published |
| Signature features | Rooftop Grand Dame Villas (seventh floor), direct Duval Street access, historic 1926 Spanish Colonial Revival building | On-site marina, motorized watercraft and boat tours on site, six pools |
| Fitness & activities | 24-hour fitness center, concierge services and tour/ticket assistance | 24-hour fitness center, bikes and water-sport rentals, boat tours and fishing on site |
| Parking & transport | On-site self-parking and valet for a fee; no airport shuttle; walkable to Old Town sites | Self parking (surcharge); RV/bus/truck parking (surcharge); not centrally located to Duval Street |
La Concha sits directly on Duval Street in Old Town, putting shops, galleries, museums and nightlife within easy walking reach.
Best pick for travelers who want to be in the thick of Old Town and avoid using a car.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina occupies a waterfront site on Stock Island with on-site marina facilities and a more resort-style setting.
Choose Hilton if your priority is boating and waterfront access rather than walking to Old Town attractions.
La Concha offers 160 rooms after a significant renovation, including rooftop Grand Dame Villas and several suite types.
La Concha emphasizes historic character, renovated rooms, and rooftop villa options for a downtown Key West stay.
Hilton lists 175 guestrooms with a range of partial ocean view and ocean view room types and many accessible options.
Hilton is a larger, full-service resort with many ocean/partial-ocean-view room options and family-accessible layouts.
La Concha’s on-site dining is Cuban-influenced and spread across several venues on Duval Street and the rooftop.
La Concha offers diverse, walkable dining tied to its Old Town setting and lively evening scene.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina provides on-site dining and casual café options, with fewer distinct food outlets listed.
Hilton covers standard resort dining needs but lists fewer distinct signature dining venues than La Concha.
La Concha has a heated outdoor pool with a rooftop pool bar suited to a downtown hotel footprint.
La Concha’s pool is convenient for hotel guests and well placed for sunset views, but it’s modest in scale.
Hilton offers extensive pool facilities and direct marina access for boating and water sports.
Hilton is the stronger choice for guests who want multiple pool areas and easy access to boating activities.
La Concha combines a 24-hour fitness center with an active Duval Street nightlife presence.
La Concha lets you mix fitness with immediate access to Old Town nightlife and evening entertainment.
Hilton has a 24-hour fitness center and daytime wellness/activity programming like yoga classes.
Hilton focuses on daytime wellness and water-based activities; nightlife is quieter on property and requires transport to Old Town.

La Concha puts you on Duval Street, within walking distance of most Old Town attractions and evening venues.

Hilton Key West Resort & Marina has on-site marina facilities, motorized watercraft and boat tours available.

Hilton lists six outdoor pools and resort-style amenities that suit guests seeking varied pool spaces.

La Concha is a 1926 Spanish Colonial Revival building with renovated rooms and seven Grand Dame rooftop villas.
La Concha: located on Duval Street, it’s within easy walking distance of many restaurants, bars and Old Town attractions.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina: it lists an on-site marina, motorized watercraft, fishing on site and boat tours in its amenities.
Yes. La Concha provides free in-room WiFi; Hilton’s supplier listing shows complimentary wireless internet access is available.
La Concha’s former rooftop Top Spa is listed as permanently closed and was converted to rooftop villas; Hilton’s listing does not publish a spa.
Explore how La Concha Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·