
La Concha Key West
Best for being in the thick of Old Town nightlife, on-site dining options, and rooftop views.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
La Concha Key West is a 4-star, larger Duval Street hotel with a rooftop pool, multiple restaurants and 160 rooms—good for travelers who want to be in the middle of Old Town and want on-site dining and event space. The Gardens Hotel is a highly rated, smaller boutique property set on Angela Street with lush grounds and two outdoor pools—appeals to travelers seeking a quiet, historic-bed-&-breakfast feel close to Duval.
Updated · about 0.3 km apart

Best for being in the thick of Old Town nightlife, on-site dining options, and rooftop views.

Best for a quieter, historic boutique stay with garden courtyards and multiple outdoor pools.
When La Concha Key West wins: Choose La Concha if you want to stay right on Duval Street with immediate access to bars, shops, and a rooftop pool and terrace; it also has more meeting and event space and multiple dining venues on-site.
When The Gardens Hotel wins: Choose The Gardens Hotel if you prefer a much smaller, highly rated property with intimate garden grounds and two outdoor pools—good for travelers who want to be near Duval but away from the busiest street noise.
Bottom line: Both are solid 4-star Key West options a short walk from the same Old Town attractions; pick La Concha for scale, rooftop views, and more on-site dining and events, and pick The Gardens Hotel for boutique charm, quieter grounds, and a strong guest rating.
| Category | La Concha Key West | The Gardens Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, historic Duval Street hotel with rooftop terraces and active bars | Quiet boutique B&B style property with historic cottages and garden courtyards |
| Location | 430 Duval Street, in the heart of Old Town next to Duval Street attractions | 526 Angela Street, a short walk from Duval Street and Old Town sights |
| Size | About 160 rooms (including 14 suites and rooftop villas) | 21 rooms |
| Who can stay / age policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | Adults-only property (guests under 16 not permitted per supplier listing) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor rooftop pool with pool bar and loungers | Two outdoor pools with poolside bar and garden seating |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues including Perla (Cuban), El Dom (coffee), Tropicado Mojito Bar and Conch Club Pool Bar | One on-site restaurant and two bars/lounges; complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast |
| Spa & wellness | Former rooftop spa space converted to rooftop villas; no active on-site full spa published | Health or beauty spa nearby (not necessarily an on-site full-service spa) |
| Known for | Rooftop villas, active Duval Street location, several dining outlets and event spaces | Lush historic setting, intimate gardens, very high guest rating |
| Accessibility & services | 24-hour front desk, 24-hour fitness center, concierge, free in-room WiFi, on-site parking (surcharge) | Concierge, two outdoor pools, free cooked-to-order breakfast, some accessibility features and wheelchair-accessible paths |
| Distance between them | about 0.3 km | |
La Concha sits at 430 Duval Street in the Key West Historic District—literally on Duval Street with immediate access to Old Town nightlife and sights.
Pick La Concha to be in the center of Old Town action, with easy walking access to major sights.
The Gardens Hotel is on Angela Street, a short walk off Duval that offers a quieter base while still being centrally located in Old Town.
Choose The Gardens for a quieter Old Town location that keeps Duval Street within easy walking distance.
La Concha has a wide range of room types and suites across 160 rooms, including seven rooftop Grand Dame Villas.
La Concha suits travelers who want variety in room types and rooftop-suite options.
The Gardens is a small property with 21 air-conditioned rooms ranging from cottages to luxury suites and carriage-house options.
The Gardens is a good choice if you prefer cottage-style rooms and a smaller property feel.
La Concha offers multiple on-site dining venues focused on Cuban-inspired cuisine, coffee and cocktails.
La Concha is best if you want varied on-site dining and a lively bar scene.
The Gardens has one on-site restaurant and a small selection of bars/lounges paired with complimentary breakfast.
The Gardens works well for quieter breakfasts and garden-side meals, but it’s not a multi-venue dining destination.
La Concha highlights a heated outdoor rooftop pool with loungers and a pool bar overlooking Duval Street.
La Concha’s rooftop pool is a social, central feature—choose it for views and easy access to Duval.
The Gardens has two outdoor pools set among its landscaped grounds, emphasizing quiet poolside relaxation.
The Gardens is better if you want multiple, tranquil pool areas in a garden setting.
La Concha offers a 24-hour fitness center and an active on-site nightlife scene via Tropicado Mojito Bar and the rooftop terrace.
Pick La Concha if you want on-site fitness and easy access to lively evening entertainment.
The Gardens focuses on quiet relaxation with garden grounds and nearby wellness options rather than on-site nightlife.
The Gardens suits travelers who prefer low-key evenings and nearby wellness services over loud nightlife.

La Concha — it sits directly on Duval Street for immediate access to shops, bars, galleries and attractions.

The Gardens Hotel — small property with garden courtyards and two outdoor pools, a quieter alternative to Duval.

La Concha — multiple venues including Perla, El Dom, Tropicado Mojito Bar and a 24/7 market.

The Gardens Hotel — very high guest rating (9.8) and a boutique, historic setting.
La Concha is better for nightlife and on-site dining with multiple bars and restaurants and its Duval Street address; The Gardens is quieter with fewer on-site dining venues.
La Concha is an all-ages property (minimum check-in age 21 for the registered guest); The Gardens is adults-only and does not permit guests under 16 per the supplier listing.
La Concha’s former rooftop spa was converted into rooftop villas and no full-service spa is published; The Gardens lists a health/beauty spa nearby rather than necessarily a full-service on-site spa.
They are a short walk from each other—about 0.3 km apart—and both put Old Town attractions and Duval Street within easy walking distance.
Explore how La Concha Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·