
La Concha Key West
Best for being in the center of Old Town and walking to Key West’s main sights, bars and restaurants.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
La Concha Key West is a four-star historic hotel on Duval Street with rooftop villas, a heated outdoor pool and several Cuban-inspired dining venues — a good pick if you want to be in Old Town within easy walk of museums, bars and shops. The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a design-forward, four-star marina resort on Stock Island with two pools, on-site marina and seafood dining — read this if you want a more modern waterfront resort experience outside downtown.
Updated · about 3.5 km apart

Best for being in the center of Old Town and walking to Key West’s main sights, bars and restaurants.

Best for travelers who want a contemporary waterfront resort with on-site marina access and resort-style pools.
When La Concha Key West wins: choose La Concha if you want to stay on Duval Street in the heart of Old Town, be steps from nightlife and museums, and prefer rooftop rooms and immediate access to the historic district.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if you prefer a quieter marina setting, modern design, on-site boat access and more resort-style pool space.
Bottom line: both are four-star properties with strong guest ratings but very different locations and feels — La Concha is the Old Town/ Duval Street choice for walkable sight-seeing and nightlife; The Perry is the option for a contemporary marina-resort stay off the downtown strip.
| Category | La Concha Key West | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Duval Street boutique with rooftop villas and lively bars | Design-forward marina resort on Stock Island with a modern, resort feel |
| Location | 430 Duval Street, in the heart of Old Town (on Duval Street) | 7001 Shrimp Road, Stock Island waterfront (marina on site) |
| Size | 160 rooms including 14 suites and seven rooftop villas | 100 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Who can stay | All ages; minimum check-in age 21 | |
| Pools | One heated outdoor pool (rooftop) with pool bar; described as small | Two outdoor pools and poolside bars |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Perla (Cuban), El Dom (cafe), Tropicado Mojito Bar, Conch Club Pool Bar | Two restaurants (incl. Matt's Stock Island) and multiple bars/pool bars |
| Spa / wellness | Former rooftop Top Spa permanently closed and space converted to rooftop villas | Not published |
| Signature feature | Seventh-floor rooftop villas and direct Duval Street address | On-site marina and waterfront location on Stock Island |
| Meetings & events | Extensive rooftop and lobby meeting rooms, multiple event spaces (largest listed ~200 capacity) | Conference space ~700 sq ft and one meeting room |
| Parking | On-site self-parking and valet for a fee | |
La Concha sits at 430 Duval Street in Old Town, placing guests steps from museums, bars and Duval Street activity.
Choose La Concha for the classic Old Town/Duval Street experience and immediate access to downtown Key West.
The Perry is on Stock Island’s waterfront and centers on its marina and resort facilities rather than being in Old Town.
Choose The Perry for a quieter waterfront base and on-site marina amenities; expect to transfer into Old Town for Duval Street nightlife.
La Concha has 160 guestrooms including 14 suites and seven seventh-floor rooftop villas created during its renovation.
La Concha is the pick if you want historic character or a rooftop villa right on Duval Street.
The Perry lists about 100 guestrooms with a range of room and suite types and some studio and suite options.
The Perry offers contemporary room types, some with marina or pool views, suitable for guests seeking resort-style guestrooms.
La Concha’s dining centers on Cuban-inspired Perla, the El Dom cafe and Tropicado Mojito Bar plus a rooftop/pool bar.
La Concha suits guests who want walkable Old Town dining plus Cuban-flavored on-site options.
The Perry’s on-site dining includes Matt’s Stock Island (seafood) and additional waterfront bars and poolside options.
The Perry focuses on seafood and casual waterfront dining suitable for resort guests and boaters.
La Concha has a heated outdoor rooftop pool with a pool bar and complimentary towels; reviews describe the pool as small.
La Concha’s rooftop pool is a sociable Duval Street-facing amenity but is small compared with full resort pools.
The Perry offers two outdoor pools, poolside bars and direct marina access on Stock Island.
The Perry is stronger for guests prioritizing pool variety and on-site boating or marina access.
La Concha has a 24-hour fitness center, a rooftop terrace popular for sunsets and on-site bars that tie directly into Duval Street’s nightlife.
La Concha blends fitness amenities with immediate access to downtown nightlife and rooftop evening options.
The Perry has a 24-hour fitness center listed among amenities and positions evening life around its restaurants, bars and quieter marina-side atmosphere.
The Perry suits guests who want fitness facilities plus relaxed waterfront evenings rather than Duval Street’s late-night scene.

La Concha — right on Duval Street with immediate walkability to museums, bars and sights.

The Perry — on-site marina and dock with boat services and waterfront rooms.

The Perry — two outdoor pools and multiple poolside bars give more pool options than La Concha’s small rooftop pool.

La Concha — rooftop terrace and villas plus Tropicado on Duval Street for live music and late-evening energy.
La Concha is directly on Duval Street in Old Town, within easy walking distance of many museums, bars and attractions; The Perry is on Stock Island and requires a short taxi/rideshare into downtown.
The Perry has two outdoor pools and multiple poolside bars; La Concha has a heated rooftop pool that is described as small.
The Perry has an on-site marina and dock and lists boat and sailing services; La Concha can arrange boat tours and water activities through its concierge but does not have a marina on site.
Both properties accept guests of all ages, with a minimum check-in age of 21 for the registered guest; confirm specific family or pet policies directly when booking.
Explore how La Concha Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·